Performance Max: Why I Finally Stopped Fighting Google's "Black Box" Campaigns
A Google Ads expert's honest journey from skeptic to believer – and what it means for your local business
I Used to Hate Performance Max (And You Probably Do Too)
Let me be brutally honest with you: When Google first rolled out Performance Max campaigns, I thought they were the worst thing to happen to Google Ads since... well, maybe ever.
Here's why I was so angry: Google basically said "Give us your money and trust us to spend it wherever we want – YouTube, Display Network, Shopping, Search – and oh, by the way, you can't control where it goes or see detailed reports about what's working."
If you've ever felt frustrated with Performance Max campaigns eating your budget without clear results, you're not alone. For three years, I told every client to avoid them like the plague.
But here's the thing: I was wrong. And if you're still avoiding Performance Max for your local business, you might be leaving serious money on the table.
The Moment Everything Changed
My conversion happened with two types of businesses that probably look a lot like yours: a few restaurant chains and some e-commerce brands.
For the restaurants, Google had basically forced us into Performance Max by discontinuing Local Search Ads. We had hundreds of locations that needed to show up in Maps, and Performance Max was our only option.
The results were initially terrible. I'm talking "dog water" performance (as my son would say about the Jets' season). We were burning cash with nothing to show for it.
But then something clicked: We switched to optimizing for conversion value instead of just conversions.
For restaurants, not all conversions are equal. A phone call is worth more than a directions request. A catering inquiry is worth more than a menu view. Once we told Performance Max which actions were actually valuable to the business, everything changed.
We started beating our old Local Search Ad performance. By a lot.
What Performance Max Actually Does (That Nobody Explains)
Here's what Google doesn't tell you clearly: Performance Max isn't just another campaign type. It's Google saying "We know your customers better than you do, and we're going to find them wherever they are."
For local businesses, this means:
Someone researching "best pizza downtown" on YouTube might see your ad
A person browsing restaurant reviews might see your promotion in the Display Network
Someone searching "Italian food near me" gets your restaurant in Maps results
All from one campaign, optimized by Google's AI across all these placements
The scary part: You can't control exactly where your ads show up. The amazing part: Google's AI is actually really good at finding customers you'd never reach otherwise.
Why I Finally Gave In (And You Should Consider It Too)
After testing Performance Max with dozens of local businesses over the past year, here's what I've learned:
1. It Actually Works (When Set Up Right)
One health insurance client was crushing it with regular Bing search ads, but we couldn't scale anymore. We threw some test budget at Bing's Performance Max version, expecting it to fail miserably.
It beat our search campaigns. Better cost per lead, higher conversion rates, more scale.
2. Google Forced Our Hand Anyway
Like it or not, Google has made Performance Max mandatory for many local business features:
Want to run Shopping campaigns? You need Performance Max.
Need Local Search Ads? They don't exist anymore – it's Performance Max.
Want to reach mobile searchers effectively? Performance Max dominates mobile placements.
3. The Transparency Got Better (Sort Of)
Google finally added some of the reporting we'd been screaming for:
Search query reports (so you can see what searches triggered your ads)
Channel performance reports (see how much spend goes to Search vs. YouTube vs. Display)
Negative keyword support (block irrelevant searches)
The Hard Truth About Performance Max for Local Businesses
It will make you uncomfortable. You're giving up control in exchange for potentially better results. Some days that trade-off feels worth it, other days it doesn't.
It requires patience. Performance Max needs 2-4 weeks to "learn" your business. During that time, it might spend money inefficiently while Google's AI figures out who your best customers are.
It's not magic. You still need good ads, clear conversion tracking, and realistic budgets. Performance Max amplifies good strategy – it doesn't fix bad fundamentals.
When Performance Max Makes Sense for Your Local Business
Use it when:
You want to reach customers across multiple Google properties (Search, Maps, YouTube, etc.)
You have clear conversion tracking set up
You can wait 3-4 weeks for optimal performance
You have multiple types of conversions with different values
Skip it when:
You only want to show up in specific placements (like just Google Search)
You need complete control over every aspect of your campaigns
Your tracking setup is messy or incomplete
You can't afford the learning period budget
My Honest Performance Max Setup Guide
If you decide to test Performance Max, here's how to avoid the mistakes I made:
1. Get Your Conversion Tracking Right First
Not all leads are equal. A phone call from someone ready to buy is worth more than someone downloading a coupon. Set up conversion values that reflect your actual business priorities.
2. Create Your Own Video Assets
Whatever you do, don't let Google create videos for you. They're universally terrible. Shoot something simple with your phone – a quick business overview, customer testimonial, or service demonstration.
3. Use Search Themes
This is one of the few controls you get. Add search themes related to your core services so Google understands what you want to be found for.
4. Set Up Audience Signals Properly
Give Google examples of your ideal customers. Think of it like creating a "lookalike audience" – people who visited your website, past customers, or people interested in related topics.
5. Add Every Extension Available
Sitelinks, callouts, location extensions, call extensions – use them all. More information gives Google more ways to make your ads relevant.
The Bottom Line
Performance Max isn't going anywhere. Google has made it clear this is the future of their advertising platform.
You have two choices:
Keep fighting it and potentially miss out on customers
Learn to work with it strategically
I chose option 2, and most of my clients are seeing better results than with traditional campaign types.
Is it perfect? Absolutely not. You'll have days when you wish you could see exactly where every dollar went.
Does it work? For most local businesses, yes – if you set it up correctly and give it time to optimize.
Your Next Steps
If you're considering Performance Max:
Start small – Test with 20-30% of your Google Ads budget
Give it time – Plan for at least 4 weeks of learning/optimization
Monitor closely – Check the channel reports weekly to see where spend is going
Be patient – The first 2 weeks might look rough while Google's AI learns
If you're already running Performance Max and frustrated with results, the issue is probably in your setup, not the campaign type itself.
The uncomfortable truth: Google's AI is getting better at finding customers than most of us are at targeting them manually. Fighting that reality doesn't help your business grow.
Have you tried Performance Max for your local business? What's been your experience? The learning curve is real, but so are the potential results when it's set up correctly.
Need help setting up or optimizing Performance Max campaigns? This is exactly the kind of strategic challenge the Rent-A-Nerd team helps local businesses navigate. Don't let Google's "black box" approach intimidate you – there are ways to make it work for your specific business goals.
Get instant access to
Local Lead Gen community for FREE
You’ll get 24/7 access to recorded audits and digital marketing news our agency provides to our clients. We’ll show you exactly how we audit client accounts and provide valuable insights for you to use on your own business